Japan's Reaction · Guide
Japanese fans clash over Mushoku Tensei III in chaotic isekai and anime ranking thread
Japanese fans in this thread are split on where top isekai series land, with Mushoku Tensei III taking the most votes in an ongoing poll. Several posters argue the tally is skewed by haters or one person voting repeatedly, while others bring up Re:Zero, Hell Mode, and Skeleton Knight in Another World II. No clear consensus forms, as the thread mixes genuine picks with complaints about anime-original filler and brigading.
These are fan opinions, not official facts.
671: Anonymous 2026/09/30(Wed) 03:27 JST
Normally it'd be Re:Zero or Mushoku Tensei, right? Honestly, it's hilarious that anyone thinks it can actually take #1.
695: Anonymous 2026/10/01(Thu) 20:13 JST
China's content growth strategy is something else. Somehow a Narou series called "A 5,000-Year-Old Herbivorous Dragon" got super popular in China, got a manga and anime there, and the anime that aired in Japan was a re-imported dub. They have their own Narou-style stuff too, but content regulations are so strict it can't grow.
721: Anonymous 2026/10/03(Sat) 16:58 JST
Eris from Mushoku Tensei punches a lot. Well, even though the anime is recent, it's one of those cases where the source material is pretty old.
30: Anonymous 2026/09/26(Sat) 13:50 JST
Mushoku Tensei...
32: Anonymous 2026/09/26(Sat) 14:36 JST
Tally so far:
Mushoku Tensei III: 5 votes
Yani Neko: 2 votes
Goodbye, Lara: 2 votes
NEEDY GIRL OVERDOSE: 1 vote
Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha EXCEEDS Gun Blaze Vengeance: 1 vote
The Demon Prince's Bride: 1 vote
Dropout Sage's Academy Dominance: 1 vote
34: Anonymous 2026/09/26(Sat) 14:54 JST
Mushoku Tensei. I'll get serious once I'm reincarnated!
40: Anonymous 2026/09/26(Sat) 15:25 JST
Goddess: "What do you want to be reincarnated as in another world?"
Me: "The hero's rib."
57: Anonymous 2026/09/27(Sun) 01:01 JST
[Tally so far]
Mushoku Tensei III: 6 votes
Goodbye, Lara: 3 votes
NEEDY GIRL OVERDOSE: 3 votes
Yani Neko: 2 votes
Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha EXCEEDS Gun Blaze Vengeance: 1 vote
The Demon Prince's Bride: 1 vote
Dropout Sage's Academy Dominance: 1 vote
Mobius Dust: 1 vote
20th Century Electricity Catalog -Eureka Evrika-: 1 vote
Goddess "What do you want to be reincarnated as?" Me "The hero's rib": 1 vote
Ghost Concert: 1 vote
Playing Death Games to Put Food on the Table: 1 vote
Ao no Miburo Season 2 Serizawa Assassination Arc: 1 vote
Yoroi Shinden Samurai Troopers: 1 vote
The Detective Is Already Dead Season 2: 1 vote
Reiwa no Dara-san: 1 vote
A Witch's Life in Mongol: 1 vote
62: Anonymous 2026/09/27(Sun) 02:06 JST
Skeleton Knight in Another World II.
The anime-original stuff is so bad it feels like they're trying to kill the series.
64: Anonymous 2026/09/27(Sun) 02:54 JST
[Tally so far]
Mushoku Tensei III: 6 votes
Goodbye, Lara: 3 votes
NEEDY GIRL OVERDOSE: 3 votes
Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha EXCEEDS Gun Blaze Vengeance: 3 votes
Yani Neko: 2 votes
[1 vote each for 15 other titles, including Hell Mode and Skeleton Knight in Another World II]
71: Anonymous 2026/09/27(Sun) 11:37 JST
[Tally so far]
Mushoku Tensei III: 6 votes
Yani Neko: 4 votes
Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha EXCEEDS Gun Blaze Vengeance: 4 votes
Goodbye, Lara: 3 votes
NEEDY GIRL OVERDOSE: 3 votes
[1 vote each for 16 other titles, including Hell Mode, Skeleton Knight II, and Torture Part-Timer's Daily Life]
116: Anonymous 2026/09/29(Tue) 14:36 JST
Mushoku Tensei III. The author's eccentricity, and Doraemon elements in the Reiwa era.
136: Anonymous 2026/09/30(Wed) 22:44 JST
The fact that Mushoku Tensei and Nanoha are the top two just shows people are naming shows with lots of haters. Without user IDs [wacchoi], you can rig the votes as much as you want.
165: Anonymous 2026/10/03(Sat) 16:42 JST
From the perspective of a trash show that would definitely gross people out if you recommended it to them: Mushoku Tensei.
173: Anonymous 2026/10/04(Sun) 11:52 JST
>>169
There are probably at least a few women who like yuri anime.
The ones with literally zero female support are stuff like Mushoku Tensei and Makeine.
202: Anonymous 2026/10/06(Tue) 08:19 JST
Lumping Hell Mode in with Mobius is rough lol. It's actually one of the more entertaining ones for a Narou [web novel] series lol.
The animation even got a little better than Season 1.
205: Anonymous 2026/10/06(Tue) 15:05 JST
Speaking in terms of KOTY [Kuso Anime of the Year], is Reincarnated Goblin the year-end monster? The main thread is nothing but people roasting it lol.
224: Anonymous 2026/10/10(Sat) 20:27 JST
>>223
By that definition, Mushoku Tensei is the undisputed #1 because of the sheer number of haters.
226: Anonymous 2026/10/10(Sat) 20:35 JST
[Tally so far] Part 2
1 vote each: Tadaima, Ojamasaremasu!, The Apothecary Diaries Season 2, Overgeared, Tougen Anki, Tokyo Revengers, FX Fighter Kurumi-chan, Kore Kaite Shine, Ojisan wa Kawaii Mono ga Osuki, The Plain-Looking Transfer Student Was My Childhood Friend, Magical Explorer, Sasaki and Peeps Season 2, Dropout Sage's Academy Dominance.
253: Anonymous 2026/10/15(Thu) 04:19 JST
This is full of sockpuppets and organized voting.
Especially Mushoku Tensei, it's super obvious one person is casting most of the votes. Do they really think nobody notices? No way.
Source thread: 毎年恒例!今年一番のクソアニメを決めるスレ(2026年版) / 【祝】鉄鍋のジャン!47試合目【アニメ化】 (5ch). Posts are translated by Manga Lounge Times. Replies are placed under the post they answer. Names and IDs are left out.
Sources
Blogs & fan discussion
- 毎年恒例!今年一番のクソアニメを決めるスレ(2026年版) (5ch) Japanese
- 【祝】鉄鍋のジャン!47試合目【アニメ化】 (5ch) Japanese
Statements backed only by blogs or fan discussion are written as what fans say, not as fact.







